
A recent post by urologist Dr. David Canes stopped me because it captured something many physicians, scientists, and patients can feel but do not always say out loud: CT scans are increasingly being used as an extension of the physical exam.
Not because the physician has a clearly articulated diagnostic question. Not because the doctor has a strong clinical reason to believe the CT scan will find the condition they are worried about. Not because the answer will necessarily change management. But because “something bad might be happening,” and the fastest way to reassure everyone is to scan.
That may sound safe. In the moment, it often feels safe. But this recent study in JAMA Internal Medicine1 should force us to ask whether the current CT scan culture is creating a different kind of risk—one that is delayed, distributed across the population, and much easier to ignore.
The study estimated that in 2023, approximately 93 million CT examinations were performed in about 61.5 million patients in the United States. Today that number is likely even higher. Using radiation-dose data and cancer-risk modeling, the authors projected that those scans could result in approximately 103,000 future radiation-induced cancers over the lifetimes of exposed patients!
And for breast cancer the use of CT scanning without sufficient diagnostic discipline can create a measurable cancer burden for this disease as well. Approximately 5,700 additional breast cancers are projected to be diagnosed (or I would argue caused) by CT scans!! That’s not inconsequential. And women aged 18–49 will account for the most projected CT-related breast cancers (~3,900 cases). Even more worrisome is that girls under 18 are expected to develop more than 600 breast cancers from CT imaging alone based on current scanning practices.
This study is a warning for radiologists, for every clinician who orders imaging in children and young patients, who have more years of life ahead of them (and are within susceptible windows of exposure) during which radiation-induced cancers could develop. The study projected cancer risk per examination was higher in children and adolescents, although the majority of projected cancers occurred in adults because adults receive far more CT scans overall.
The risk of any one CT may be small for an individual patient, but when repeated or when exposed during a vulnerable period in life when the indication is not strong, the risk may outweigh the benefit. And by the time cancer appears, the initiating exposure may be years or decades in the past. The harm is delayed. The individual causal chain is difficult to reconstruct. The system that generated the exposure has moved on. And because the risk was distributed across millions of people, no single decision-maker feels responsible.
That is why population-level prevention requires discipline at the point of exposure.
We already understand this in other contexts. We regulate carcinogens in air, water, food, workplaces, and consumer products not because every exposure guarantees cancer, but because repeated exposures across large populations can shift risk. Medical radiation should be held to the same basic logic: use it when the benefit is clear, optimize the dose, and avoid exposure when the test is unlikely to change care.
And as a patient, here are some things to consider:
Ask why: ask your physician to justify every CT especially if being ordered for children or if you’re under 40; ultrasound or MRI may be a better option. Use one phase CT, not three: Single-phase CT scans drastically reduce radiation exposure. And track cumulative dose in your medical records—especially for chronic conditions. Your electronic health record systems should surface repeat scans. If not, ask your physician or remind them of your prior CT scans.
This is not an argument against CT scans. It is an argument against turning CT scans into a reflex, against using radiation as reassurance. It’s an argument against allowing financial incentives, liability fears, time pressure, and diagnostic uncertainty to replace clinical judgment.
There is a place for CT scans. We need CT scans. But they need to be used with purpose and should not replace the exam and should not be use as a substitute for thinking.
Via https://brownstone.org/articles/how-todays-ct-scan-culture-could-be-creating-tomorrows-cancers/


(Photo credit: Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP)



(Photo credit: Evelyn Hockstein/Pool/AFP via Getty Images)